URTH |
From: Michael Straight <straight@email.unc.edu> Subject: (urth) Westwind (Spoilers) Date: Fri, 25 Jul 1997 14:10:37 [Posted from URTH, a mailing list about Gene Wolfe's New Sun and other works] Since the whorl list has been fairly quiet, I decided I could subscribe to the urth list without drowning, and thought I'd say "Hi" with some comments about the short story "Westwind." Spoilers Ho! Fore! I can't remember which anthology I read this in, but I read Wolfe's introduction first (where he makes a few comments about each of the stories) trusting him not to spoil any of the stories, but I think he truly ruined this one for me. The story is wonderfully ambiguous about whether the ruler (I forget what he's called in the story) is a benevolent God-like figure who loves and secretly carries on a personal relationship with all his subjects (or at least all of the "good" ones), or a dictator using computer technology and trickery as a form of social control (convincing subjects who live in poverty - in contrast to the beauty seen when he addresses them all on the big screen - that they have an exclusive, secret relationship with the ruler so that they won't want to oppose him). I've wondered if the story isn't something of a Rorschach test revealing the readers own predispositions, whether people who do not believe in a benevolent God are more likely to interpret the story as sinister (or maybe most sf readers would interpret it as sinister since the "benevolent ruler turns out to be nasty dictator" is such a common idea in sf). Anyone want to chime in on how you interpreted the story and whether you think that reveals anything about yourself? I'll never know what my initial reaction would have been because in the introduction, Wolfe says that the story is about God and so I interpreted it in a positive light and didn't notice the possible sinister aspects until later. But there's more to discuss here than first reactions. Can the story be read in a positive light? Even if he hasn't outright lied to people, the leader seems to have mislead many of them (all of them?) into thinking they are each the only Westwind. Is everyone Westwind or just those who voiced support for the leader? (Do you get to be Westwind because you support him, or do you support him because you're Westwind?) Can the leader be human or must he either be a multi-tasking computer or divine (I'm thinking of the fact that he seems able to talk to all the Westwinds at the same time)? -Rostrum