URTH |
From: m.driussi@genie.com Subject: (urth) Eco's tic Date: Tue, 25 Aug 98 20:21:00 GMT Rostrum, Re: FOUCAULT'S PENDULUM (which incidentally ties in with PEACE by way of NECRONOMICON). I know what you mean in saying "we want more mysteries, not answers," and I know you don't mean to be absolutist about it--since there =are= limits: if an author keeps providing mysteries without =satisfying= solutions, that's no good either. But mainly I want to argue that FOUCAULT'S PENDULUM, which I didn't like very much (agreeing with you, I'm guessing), is on second glance rather a lot like THE NAME OF THE ROSE (which I liked better). They both in their conclusions involve a destruction of the "fiction" which has been so carefully built up between the author and the reader over the course of the novel. This amounts to a visceral "thumbing of the nose" or sucker punch from Eco to reader. Very po-mo. Or in a different harsh light, one might say it points to a failure of artistic vision--at the very least, it suggests that Eco is a one trick pony: the guy can't write an ending; he loses steam and takes it out on the reader in his frustration. So, IMHO, ILLUMINATUS! and HOLY BLOOD, HOLY GRAIL and THE CRYING OF LOT 49 (to name just three works that cover similar territory) are successful and satisfying where FOUCAULT'S PENDULUM is not; yet these three works give plenty of answers to the mysteries they pose. =mantis= *More Wolfe info & archive of this list at http://www.urth.net/urth/