From: "James Wynn"
Subject: RE: (urth) Typhon and Severian Date: Mon, 10 Mar 2003 09:31:48 -0600 Don postulates: The only certainty is that Dorcas is Ouen's mother. Ouen denies ever impregnating Katherine, and the only evidence that Ouen could be Severian's father is that they look strikingly similar in profile. (Sword and Citadel, p 402). This is hardly compelling. In addition, it is thematically weak. If Dorcas is Severian's grandmother then he is committing incest in a manner that makes no sense mythopoeicly. The incest only makes sense if she is his sister or his mother. Equally, the archetypes clinging to Severian's character point in a different direction. Ouen makes a much stronger adoptive father in the vein of Joseph the carpenter, or Sir Hector... Crush tries to speed Don on his way: Mythopoetically speaking, (if it is applicable here) Dorcas should be Severian's mother AND sister (as Isis was to Horus). I'm not sure I see how Ouen works as Hector or Joseph. Malrubius works better in this role. Having not read 'King Jesus' my problems with the Herod-Jesus/Typhon-Severian analogy is mythopoetic: I do agree that Typhon takes the thematic role of Herod at times - I haven't decided with Typhon's meeting with Severian in 'Urth of the New Sun' more closely parallels Herod and Jesus or Herod and John the Baptist. According to Wolfe, tBotNS is a toying with Sun symbolism. So Severian would be expected to parallel Jesus to some extent as the 'Sun of Righteousness' (Malachi 4:2). But how is Severian, as a Sun symbol, a son of Typhon? According to Graves, Typhon is Set. And both are the dragon that devours (kills) the Sun during an eclipse and is killed by Horus. Graves also associates Typhon with the Python of Hera, whom Apollo simultaneously kills and appropriates as his servant in prophecy. So whether one views Severian as Osirus or Horus or Apollo, how is he mythopoetically a son, heir, or descendent of Typhon? Perhaps Graves justified this association in 'King Jesus'? * Crush --