From: "Chris" 
Subject: Re: (urth) Severian's motive for memory
Date: Wed, 09 Jul 2003 17:42:12 +0000

I'm completely willing to entertain the concept of BotNS as a piece of 
propaganda, but in practical terms I just can't see it as beneficial to 
Severian's position *politically*. In many ways it's counter-productive, but 
the most important one is that it paints him into a corner w.r.t. the New 
Sun. The book leaves off with him about to be tested. Any of his subjects 
who read it after that point will expect a new sun to have arrived, and if 
they don't get it then they will assume that Severian is a failure. If Sev 
is in fact expecting to provide a new sun, then he doesn't really need a 
book to assure his political power. And if he's not, then by no means does 
it serve his purpose to create an immediate expectation of one - he would 
benefit more by ending his book by implying that the test will take place at 
some point in the distant future ("If you're just patient enough, Severian 
will fix all this one day.")

IMHO if the book is a piece of propaganda, it is probably for religious 
reasons (and not necessarily hypocritical ones - he may be proselytizing for 
beliefs that he personally holds).

Also, if you do assume that Severian had a copy of BotNS then you have said 
a mouthful. There are several different ways you can go with it (I 
considered drawing a diagram for myself, but of course it wouldn't translate 
well to posting), but the implications of any of them are overwhelming 
enough that they tend to set the tone of how you interpret the entire book. 
They also tend to preclude a simple, propagandistic reading.

On a side note, is anyone using the name "Civet"? I've been fascinated by 
these little beasties lately.

Chris

Marc said:
>I don't expect that everyone will agree with me on this one, but I think it
>justifies Severian's CONTINUAL claims of perfect memory a bit.
>
>First off, let's think about Severian's audience in Book of the New Sun: he 
>is
>the autarch, and he wants to quell the angry exultants who don't like
>commoners or half-breeds on the throne, the ones who gave Appian so much
>trouble that he had to keep hostages to kill if a family got out of hand 
>(his
>concubines).  Severian also has to worry about threats from outer space,
>threats from sea powers that he doesn't understand, and threats from the
>north.  In the popularity polls, I think this would make a ruler a lot 
>lower
>than Nixon.  Nixon didn't torture people from birth.  So what does Severian
>do?  He writes a narrative in which he purports to be a religious figure of
>DESTINY - his fate pre-ordained from the beginning.  He uses ghosts of old
>masters to put forth the idea that the highest form of government is 
>loyalty
>to the person of the monarch: ie - whoever is in charge now is the big 
>boss,
>and no hostile takeover should be allowed since he is like God.  Indeed,
>Triskele is used in this scene as a sample worshiper of Severian.  He 
>placates
>the insurgents like Vodalus by claiming from the very beginning that he's 
>on
>their side, and always has been.  He presents the Ascians in a more
>sympathetic light than can be expected because he probably wants the war to
>end.  He tries very hard to make it clear that he is the ordained master, 
>the
>New Sun.  Note that it is not this Severian who brings the new sun and 
>writes
>Urth of the New Sun - that is another one.  Notice that over and over 
>Severian
>will try to show how his destiny was inescapable: he was forced to eat 
>Thecla
>(who was definitely a supporter of Vodalus and Abia, since she wanted to go 
>up
>to Lake Diuturna when she got out and talked about pelagic depths all the
>time), forced to eat the old autarch, and destined for a throne without 
>real
>desire for it.  In many ways, the first four books can be seen as a 
>political
>document apologizing for his rise to autarch.  He has been manipulated by
>powers which should not be meddled with, but from the beginning he had some
>presentiment of that great destiny.
>
>Why the insistence that his memory is perfect?  For one thing, he wants his
>audience to believe that once and for all he is the commonwealth - all the
>memories of its rulers live on in his perfect mind.  Another reason is that 
>I
>believe that he has lived his life over and over again - there is little
>evidence that Severian is going to go back in time after the end of Urth of
>the New Sun and be an autarch whose forebrain will be eaten in the line of
>succession.  And yes, Severian DID have access to the Book of Canog, which 
>was
>the Book of the New Sun, and the story of his life.  It was one of the four
>that he checked out for Thecla, according to Wolfe in his little essay in
>Plan(e)t Engineering.  So he could have read his life before.
>
>In any case, the political agenda of the first four books (which I insist 
>were
>written by a very different Severian than Urth of the New Sun) is quite 
>clear:
>Severian was destined to be the ruler, and possibly save the Urth, so don't
>rebel or complain.  Or he'll torture you, because he's good at that, too. 
>And
>he's not afraid of putting people in their place violently, like Eata.
>And he won't ever, ever forget if you betray him.
>Marc Aramini
>
>
>
>--

_________________________________________________________________
Tired of spam? Get advanced junk mail protection with MSN 8. 
http://join.msn.com/?page=features/junkmail


--