Date: Sun, 13 Jul 2003 16:34:13 -0500
From: James Jordan 
Subject: Re: (urth) Sev's not-so-perfect memory

Perhaps this point has been made, but what is even more striking about the 
contradictions is that this is the SECOND time Sev. has written this, and 
evidently the SAME Sev. Wouldn't he catch these errors the second time 
through?
         Which makes we wonder if they really are errors. I'd have to look 
at all of them carefully, and I'm not rereading the books now. Is it 
possible both other boys pointed out the pikes, maybe one first and the 
other saying, "Yeah, look!" Is is possible Vodalus handed his weapon to one 
person with the intention of its being handed on to a third? Are some or 
all of these contradictions reconcilable?
         Maybe not. But given that they all seem to be "small" errors, it 
makes me wonder.

Nutria


--